‘All Star Cafe’ Wagner Set to be Sold

Robert Edward Auctions was schedule to offer a T206 Honus Wagner in its spring 2013 auction. This one was once owned by actor Charlie Sheen, who loaned the card for display at the All Star Cafe in New York back in the 1990s.

In 1998, workers in the Cafe actually successfully stole the card and sold it under the table to a private buyer. They stole the original and put a copy of the card back in the display case. For a while, nobody could tell the difference because of the viewing distance. Once they successfully stole the card, the nephew of the head chef at the cafe was assigned to sell the card to someone for cash. The nephew came across Al Rosen, the well-known dealer known as “Mr.  Mint”.  The man told Rosen that his grandfather saved the card and gave it to him as a gift.  Rosen believed him and purchased the card in cash and it seemed like they got away clean with this robbery.

PSA 1 Honus Wagner cardAfter a while, there was another display case in the cafe that apparently had been broken accidentally. The workers saw this as another golden opportunity presenting itself and they began planning their next move. This time, the display case housed  the 1934 Goudey uncut sheet with #106 Nap Lajoie included in the sheet, also owned by Sheen.   As the workers put their plan into action, again everything seemed to go smoothly and they decided to cut the sheet into pieces and sell the cards separately in order to avoid suspicion of how such a thing was acquired. The only problem with this second plan was that they never bothered to put a replacement in the case! This triggered an FBI investigation and they soon found that the Wagner card that now sat in the case was a fake.  As everything began to unravel, the chefs were caught and the FBI solved the case and returned all of the stolen cards to Sheen, the rightful owner.

In 2001, that very Wagner card that was housed in the All Star Cafe for so many years was actually sold at auction for $78,000. Contrary to popular belief, the low grade T206 Wagner cards actually have increased in value much more quickly than the higher grade cards have gone up. This is simply because the demand for the lower grade Wagner cards are much higher and continue to increae.  The ‘All Star Café’ Wagner most recently sold in 2009 for a total of $399,500! As you can see, the value of Wagner cards rarely does anything but go up and this card could be a great investment for anyone who can afford it.

On April 6, 2013, a PSA 5 (miscut) Wagner sold at auction for $2.1 million, just a few years after being purchased for $1.62 million.

The T206 "All Star Cafe" Wagner set to be sold by REA has a reserve of $100,000.

The auction catalogs were scheduled to be shipped about April 19, 2013 and the auction will close May 19.

1948-49 Leaf HONUS WAGNER Pirates HOF #70 SGC 5
1948-49 Leaf HONUS WAGNER Pirates HOF #70 SGC 5 $184.99
Time Remaining: 1d 4h 42m
Buy It Now for only: $184.99
1913 National Game HONUS WAGNER Pittsburgh SGC MINT 9
1913 National Game HONUS WAGNER Pittsburgh SGC MINT 9 $1,499.99
Time Remaining: 1d 9h 5m
Buy It Now for only: $1,499.99
2011 Topps CMGR-11 Honus Wagner SGC 98 Gem Mint 10 Pittsburgh Pirates
2011 Topps CMGR-11 Honus Wagner SGC 98 Gem Mint 10 Pittsburgh Pirates $19.07
Time Remaining: 2d 16h 48m
Buy It Now for only: $19.07
1910 E90-2 American Caramel Honus Wagner HOF SGC 30 2 1242100-004
1910 E90-2 American Caramel Honus Wagner HOF SGC 30 2 1242100-004 $7,500.00
Time Remaining: 3d 2h 15m
Buy It Now for only: $7,500.00
1980 Exhibits Hall of Fame Honus Wagner SGC 60 EX 5 21090
1980 Exhibits Hall of Fame Honus Wagner SGC 60 EX 5 21090 $40.00
Time Remaining: 3d 3h 54m
Buy It Now for only: $40.00
1963 Bazooka ATG Greats Silver #10 Honus Wagner SGC 88 NMMT 8 26721
1963 Bazooka ATG Greats Silver #10 Honus Wagner SGC 88 NMMT 8 26721 $100.00
Time Remaining: 3d 4h 1m
Buy It Now for only: $100.00
1951 Topps Connie Mack's Honus Wagner Pop-up Card SGC
1951 Topps Connie Mack's Honus Wagner Pop-up Card SGC $495.00
Time Remaining: 3d 16h 27m
Buy It Now for only: $495.00
1948 Leaf #70 Honus Wagner BEAUTY!! HOF SGC 86 7.5 !!!!
1948 Leaf #70    Honus Wagner    BEAUTY!!  HOF   SGC 86  7.5  !!!! $539.40
Time Remaining: 5d 4h 8m
Buy It Now for only: $539.40
1913 National Game HONUS WAGNER - Pittsburgh - SGC 80
1913 National Game HONUS WAGNER - Pittsburgh - SGC 80 $395.00
Time Remaining: 5d 9h 30m
Buy It Now for only: $395.00
1911 E94 George Close Candy Honus Wagner SGC 30 (2) *Rare*
1911 E94 George Close Candy Honus Wagner SGC 30 (2)  *Rare* $4,299.00
Time Remaining: 6d 6h 46m
Buy It Now for only: $4,299.00
1909 E92 Dockman & Sons HONUS WAGNER Throwing Pittsburgh SGC A
1909 E92 Dockman & Sons HONUS WAGNER Throwing Pittsburgh SGC A $1,799.99
Time Remaining: 7d 8h 44m
Buy It Now for only: $1,799.99
1940 Play Ball R335 #168 Honus Wagner SGC 5 EX Pittsburgh Pirates HOF
1940 Play Ball R335 #168 Honus Wagner SGC 5 EX Pittsburgh Pirates HOF $259.00
Time Remaining: 8d 6h 40m
Buy It Now for only: $259.00

« Previous1234